Man On The Street Whisky

Whisky Rankings

Weighted tasting scores across members, events, and whisky styles.

81 whiskies matched

Whisky Type

Brand

User

Event

Age

Minimum Samples

Sort By

Weighted score gives more trust to whiskies with more ratings. More samples = closer to its own average; fewer samples = pulled toward the overall average.

Bayesian weighted average: Score = (n / (n + 3)) × Avg Total + (3 / (n + 3)) × Global Avg 🤔

Rank #1

15 Year Old

Dalwhinnie

Weighted: 15.43

Avg: 15.89

9 samples

Rank #2

10 Year Old

Ardbeg

Weighted: 15.30

Avg: 15.92

6 samples

Rank #3

16 Year Old

Bowmore

Weighted: 15.30

Avg: 15.92

6 samples

Rank #4

12 Year Old

The Singleton

Weighted: 15.29

Avg: 16.20

4 samples

Rank #5

12 Year Old

Aberlour

Weighted: 15.28

Avg: 15.65

10 samples

Rank #6

10 Year Old

Laphroaig

Weighted: 15.25

Avg: 15.54

12 samples

Rank #7

16 Year Old

Lagavulin

Weighted: 15.22

Avg: 15.71

7 samples

Rank #8

18 Year Old

Glenfiddich

Weighted: 15.21

Avg: 15.90

5 samples

Rank #9

12 Year Old

Bowmore

Weighted: 15.19

Avg: 15.38

17 samples

Rank #10

14 Year Old

Tomatin

Weighted: 15.17

Avg: 16.00

4 samples

Rank #11

12 Year Old

Auchentoshan

Weighted: 15.17

Avg: 15.50

10 samples

Rank #12

(Original) 10 Yrs

Glenmoreangie

Weighted: 15.12

Avg: 16.17

3 samples

Rank #13

12 Year Old

GlenDronach

Weighted: 15.09

Avg: 15.70

5 samples

Rank #14

12 Year Old

CAOL ILA

Weighted: 15.01

Avg: 15.23

13 samples

Rank #15

Sexton

Weighted: 14.98

Avg: 15.52

5 samples

Rank #16

The Miltonduff - 15 Year Old

Ballantine’s

Weighted: 14.97

Avg: 15.36

7 samples

Rank #17

Royal Salute

Chivas

Weighted: 14.97

Avg: 15.42

6 samples

Rank #18

Experimental Series - Fire & Cane

Glenfiddich

Weighted: 14.95

Avg: 15.83

3 samples

Rank #19

15 Year Old

Knockando

Weighted: 14.95

Avg: 15.33

7 samples

Rank #20

15 Year Old

Bowmore

Weighted: 14.86

Avg: 15.25

6 samples

Rank #21

12 Year Old

GlenAllachie

Weighted: 14.70

Avg: 14.94

8 samples

Rank #22

12 Year Old

Tomatin

Weighted: 14.67

Avg: 14.78

16 samples

Rank #23

Gold Label

Johnnie Walker

Weighted: 14.62

Avg: 14.86

7 samples

Rank #24

10 Year Old

Ledaig

Weighted: 14.61

Avg: 14.94

5 samples

Rank #25

11 Year Old

Bowmore

Weighted: 14.58

Avg: 14.83

6 samples

Rank #26

18 year old

Chivas

Weighted: 14.58

Avg: 14.83

6 samples

Rank #27

12 Year Old

The Glenlivet

Weighted: 14.57

Avg: 14.95

4 samples

Rank #28

The Irishman

Weighted: 14.56

Avg: 14.86

5 samples

Rank #29

10 Year Old

Jura

Weighted: 14.53

Avg: 14.80

5 samples

Rank #30

Connemara

Weighted: 14.46

Avg: 14.70

5 samples

Rank #31

Gold Reserve

Cardhu

Weighted: 14.46

Avg: 14.70

5 samples

Rank #32

12 Year

Cardhu

Weighted: 14.43

Avg: 15.50

1 samples

Rank #33

Heavily Peated

Port Charlotte

Weighted: 14.43

Avg: 15.50

1 samples

Rank #34

12 Year Old

Glenkinchie

Weighted: 14.40

Avg: 14.60

5 samples

Rank #35

Teeling

Weighted: 14.35

Avg: 14.52

5 samples

Rank #36

The Journey

Sailors Home

Weighted: 14.28

Avg: 14.50

3 samples

Rank #37

PURE Malt Whisky

Kuratoshi

Weighted: 14.21

Avg: 14.30

5 samples

Rank #38

10 Year Old

Talisker

Weighted: 14.18

Avg: 14.50

1 samples

Rank #39

The Original

Monkey Shoulder

Weighted: 14.18

Avg: 14.50

1 samples

Rank #40

Amrut Single Malt

Amrut

Weighted: 14.17

Avg: 14.25

4 samples

Rank #41

Slane - Irish Whiskey

Slane

Weighted: 14.15

Avg: 14.20

5 samples

Rank #42

VAT 02

Glenfiddich

Weighted: 14.13

Avg: 14.17

6 samples

Rank #43

Revival

Glenglassaugh

Weighted: 14.13

Avg: 14.16

5 samples

Rank #44

15 year old

Chivas

Weighted: 14.11

Avg: 14.13

6 samples

Rank #45

The Smokey 10

Benriach

Weighted: 14.09

Avg: 14.10

5 samples

Rank #46

20 Year Old

Greign

Weighted: 14.08

Avg: 14.08

6 samples

Rank #47

Drumshanbo

Weighted: 14.05

Avg: 14.00

1 samples

Rank #48

Green Label

Johnnie Walker

Weighted: 14.05

Avg: 14.05

11 samples

Rank #49

12 Year Old

Aberfeldy

Weighted: 13.98

Avg: 13.95

11 samples

Rank #50

Dark Storm

Talisker

Weighted: 13.97

Avg: 13.92

6 samples

Rank #51

Blue Label

Johnnie Walker

Weighted: 13.96

Avg: 13.90

5 samples

Rank #52

Divergence

Weighted: 13.96

Avg: 13.90

5 samples

Rank #53

Swing

Johnnie Walker

Weighted: 13.90

Avg: 13.80

5 samples

Rank #54

Black Label

Johnnie Walker

Weighted: 13.86

Avg: 13.75

6 samples

Rank #55

Double Black

Johnnie Walker

Weighted: 13.71

Avg: 13.50

5 samples

Rank #56

10 Year Old

Bushmills

Weighted: 13.64

Avg: 13.50

9 samples

Rank #57

Amber Rock

Cardhu

Weighted: 13.63

Avg: 13.42

6 samples

Rank #58

Double Wood

The Balvenie

Weighted: 13.55

Avg: 12.00

1 samples

Rank #59

19 Year Old

Glenmoreangie

Weighted: 13.52

Avg: 13.25

6 samples

Rank #60

Red Label

Johnnie Walker

Weighted: 13.46

Avg: 13.10

5 samples

Rank #61

12 Year Old

Glen Moray

Weighted: 13.41

Avg: 13.08

6 samples

Rank #62

Drumshanbo - Galanta 2022

Drumshanbo

Weighted: 13.34

Avg: 12.90

5 samples

Rank #63

VAT 01

Glenfiddich

Weighted: 13.30

Avg: 12.92

6 samples

Rank #64

12 Year Old

Old Pulteney

Weighted: 13.24

Avg: 12.83

6 samples

Rank #65

Select

Laphroaig

Weighted: 13.24

Avg: 12.83

6 samples

Rank #66

12 Year Old

GlenGrant

Weighted: 13.22

Avg: 12.86

7 samples

Rank #67

Cù Bòcan

Tomatin

Weighted: 13.22

Avg: 12.86

7 samples

Rank #68

12 Year Old

Glenfiddich

Weighted: 13.19

Avg: 12.75

6 samples

Rank #69

12 Year Old

GlenGrant

Weighted: 13.13

Avg: 12.67

6 samples

Rank #70

American Oak Reserve

Auchentoshan

Weighted: 13.02

Avg: 12.50

6 samples

Rank #71

Suntory

The Chita

Weighted: 12.92

Avg: 12.43

7 samples

Rank #72

10 Year Old

GlenGrant

Weighted: 12.83

Avg: 12.22

6 samples

Rank #73

Triple Distilled

Proper No. Twelve

Weighted: 12.80

Avg: 12.17

6 samples

Rank #74

13 year old Tequila

Chivas

Weighted: 12.69

Avg: 12.00

6 samples

Rank #75

12 year old

Chivas

Weighted: 12.47

Avg: 11.67

6 samples

Rank #76

Indri

Indri-Trīni

Weighted: 12.42

Avg: 11.71

7 samples

Rank #77

Select

Kavalan

Weighted: 12.22

Avg: 11.43

7 samples

Rank #78

13 year old Extra

Chivas

Weighted: 11.94

Avg: 10.88

6 samples

Rank #79

Nirvana

Paul John

Weighted: 11.63

Avg: 10.42

6 samples

Rank #80

10 Year Old

Benriach

Weighted: 11.52

Avg: 10.25

6 samples

Rank #81

Kirin Single Grain Fuji

Kirin

Weighted: 11.47

Avg: 10.17

6 samples

#	Whisky	Brand	Type	Weighted	Avg Total		App.	Nose	Taste	Finish
1	15 Year Old	Dalwhinnie	Single Malt	15.43	15.89	9	3.78	3.94	4.17	4.00
2	10 Year Old	Ardbeg	Single Malt	15.30	15.92	6	3.58	4.25	4.00	4.08
3	16 Year Old	Bowmore	Single Malt	15.30	15.92	6	3.75	3.83	4.00	4.33
4	12 Year Old	The Singleton	Single Malt	15.29	16.20	4	4.00	4.00	4.13	4.08
5	12 Year Old	Aberlour	Single Malt	15.28	15.65	10	3.85	3.75	3.95	4.10
6	10 Year Old	Laphroaig	Single Malt	15.25	15.54	12	3.75	3.98	3.89	3.93
7	16 Year Old	Lagavulin	Single Malt	15.22	15.71	7	3.79	3.93	3.79	4.21
8	18 Year Old	Glenfiddich	Single Malt	15.21	15.90	5	3.70	3.80	4.20	4.20
9	12 Year Old	Bowmore	Single Malt	15.19	15.38	17	3.82	3.84	3.98	3.74
10	14 Year Old	Tomatin	Single Malt	15.17	16.00	4	3.88	3.88	4.00	4.25
11	12 Year Old	Auchentoshan	Single Malt	15.17	15.50	10	4.15	3.80	3.95	3.60
12	(Original) 10 Yrs	Glenmoreangie	Single Malt	15.12	16.17	3	4.17	3.83	3.83	4.33
13	12 Year Old	GlenDronach	Single Malt	15.09	15.70	5	3.90	3.82	3.96	4.02
14	12 Year Old	CAOL ILA	Single Malt	15.01	15.23	13	3.46	3.85	4.00	3.92
15	Sexton	Sexton	Triple Distilled	14.98	15.52	5	3.90	3.96	3.86	3.80
16	The Miltonduff - 15 Year Old	Ballantine’s	Single Malt	14.97	15.36	7	3.57	3.64	4.07	4.07
17	Royal Salute	Chivas	Blended Whisky	14.97	15.42	6	3.83	3.33	4.17	4.08
18	Experimental Series - Fire & Cane	Glenfiddich	Single Malt	14.95	15.83	3	4.50	3.33	4.00	4.00
19	15 Year Old	Knockando	Single Malt	14.95	15.33	7	3.36	3.54	4.21	4.21
20	15 Year Old	Bowmore	Single Malt	14.86	15.25	6	3.75	3.92	3.75	3.83
21	12 Year Old	GlenAllachie	Single Malt	14.70	14.94	8	4.57	4.00	3.81	3.57
22	12 Year Old	Tomatin	Single Malt	14.67	14.78	16	3.84	3.44	3.69	3.81
23	Gold Label	Johnnie Walker	Blended Whisky	14.62	14.86	7	3.86	3.50	3.79	3.71
24	10 Year Old	Ledaig	Single Malt	14.61	14.94	5	3.82	3.76	3.56	3.80
25	11 Year Old	Bowmore	Single Malt	14.58	14.83	6	3.50	3.42	3.92	4.00
26	18 year old	Chivas	Blended Whisky	14.58	14.83	6	3.33	3.17	4.17	4.17
27	12 Year Old	The Glenlivet	Single Malt	14.57	14.95	4	3.63	3.58	4.00	3.75
28	The Irishman	The Irishman	Triple Distilled	14.56	14.86	5	3.80	3.60	4.00	3.46
29	10 Year Old	Jura	Single Malt	14.53	14.80	5	4.20	3.50	3.40	3.70
30	Connemara	Connemara	Single Malt	14.46	14.70	5	3.30	3.80	3.80	3.80
31	Gold Reserve	Cardhu	Single Malt	14.46	14.70	5	4.10	3.30	3.80	3.50
32	12 Year	Cardhu	Single Malt	14.43	15.50	1	4.00	4.00	3.50	4.00
33	Heavily Peated	Port Charlotte	Single Malt	14.43	15.50	1	4.50	4.50	3.00	3.50
34	12 Year Old	Glenkinchie	Single Malt	14.40	14.60	5	3.40	3.70	3.60	3.90
35	Teeling	Teeling	Single Malt	14.35	14.52	5	3.60	3.66	3.80	3.46
36	The Journey	Sailors Home	Blended Whisky	14.28	14.50	3	4.67	3.33	2.67	3.83
37	PURE Malt Whisky	Kuratoshi	Single Malt	14.21	14.30	5	3.60	3.30	3.90	3.50
38	10 Year Old	Talisker	Single Malt	14.18	14.50	1	3.00	4.00	3.50	4.00
39	The Original	Monkey Shoulder	Blended Malt	14.18	14.50	1	4.00	4.00	4.00	2.50
40	Amrut Single Malt	Amrut	Single Malt	14.17	14.25	4	4.25	3.25	3.88	2.88
41	Slane - Irish Whiskey	Slane	Blended Whisky	14.15	14.20	5	3.90	3.00	3.50	3.80
42	VAT 02	Glenfiddich	Single Malt	14.13	14.17	6	3.67	3.50	3.58	3.42
43	Revival	Glenglassaugh	Single Malt	14.13	14.16	5	3.50	3.26	3.70	3.70
44	15 year old	Chivas	Blended Whisky	14.11	14.13	6	3.42	3.05	3.92	3.75
45	The Smokey 10	Benriach	Single Malt	14.09	14.10	5	3.90	3.20	3.70	3.30
46	20 Year Old	Greign	Single Grain	14.08	14.08	6	3.58	3.33	3.50	3.67
47	Drumshanbo	Drumshanbo	Single Pot Still Irish Whiskey	14.05	14.00	1	4.00	4.00	3.00	3.00
48	Green Label	Johnnie Walker	Blended Malt	14.05	14.05	11	3.50	3.41	3.64	3.50
49	12 Year Old	Aberfeldy	Single Malt	13.98	13.95	11	3.27	3.45	3.64	3.59
50	Dark Storm	Talisker	Single Malt	13.97	13.92	6	3.33	3.42	3.83	3.33
51	Blue Label	Johnnie Walker	Blended Whisky	13.96	13.90	5	3.50	3.40	3.40	3.60
52	Divergence	Divergence	Single Malt	13.96	13.90	5	4.00	3.60	3.20	3.10
53	Swing	Johnnie Walker	Blended Whisky	13.90	13.80	5	3.40	3.40	3.40	3.60
54	Black Label	Johnnie Walker	Blended Whisky	13.86	13.75	6	3.58	3.92	3.17	3.08
55	Double Black	Johnnie Walker	Blended Whisky	13.71	13.50	5	3.40	3.20	3.50	3.40
56	10 Year Old	Bushmills	Triple Distilled	13.64	13.50	9	3.33	3.17	3.61	3.39
57	Amber Rock	Cardhu	Single Malt	13.63	13.42	6	3.33	3.17	3.42	3.50
58	Double Wood	The Balvenie	Single Malt	13.55	12.00	1	3.00	4.00	2.00	3.00
59	19 Year Old	Glenmoreangie	Single Malt	13.52	13.25	6	3.58	3.17	3.25	3.25
60	Red Label	Johnnie Walker	Blended Whisky	13.46	13.10	5	3.20	3.10	3.50	3.30
61	12 Year Old	Glen Moray	Single Malt	13.41	13.08	6	3.00	3.08	3.50	3.50
62	Drumshanbo - Galanta 2022	Drumshanbo	Single Malt	13.34	12.90	5	3.20	3.00	3.70	3.00
63	VAT 01	Glenfiddich	Single Malt	13.30	12.92	6	3.50	3.25	3.17	3.00
64	12 Year Old	Old Pulteney	Single Malt	13.24	12.83	6	2.75	3.50	3.50	3.08
65	Select	Laphroaig	Single Malt	13.24	12.83	6	3.42	3.42	3.08	2.92
66	12 Year Old	GlenGrant	Single Malt	13.22	12.86	7	3.29	3.14	3.43	3.00
67	Cù Bòcan	Tomatin	Single Malt	13.22	12.86	7	3.29	3.14	3.57	2.86
68	12 Year Old	Glenfiddich	Single Malt	13.19	12.75	6	3.42	2.75	3.08	3.50
69	12 Year Old	GlenGrant	Single Malt	13.13	12.67	6	3.17	2.83	3.50	3.17
70	American Oak Reserve	Auchentoshan	Single Malt	13.02	12.50	6	3.17	3.17	3.25	2.92
71	Suntory	The Chita	Single Grain	12.92	12.43	7	2.57	3.14	3.43	3.29
72	10 Year Old	GlenGrant	Single Malt	12.83	12.22	6	2.55	3.58	3.50	3.10
73	Triple Distilled	Proper No. Twelve	Triple Distilled	12.80	12.17	6	3.08	2.92	3.50	2.67
74	13 year old Tequila	Chivas	Blended Whisky	12.69	12.00	6	2.67	2.92	3.33	3.08
75	12 year old	Chivas	Blended Whisky	12.47	11.67	6	2.50	2.75	3.33	3.08
76	Indri	Indri-Trīni	Single Malt	12.42	11.71	7	3.43	3.00	2.57	2.71
77	Select	Kavalan	Single Malt	12.22	11.43	7	2.93	3.07	2.93	2.50
78	13 year old Extra	Chivas	Blended Whisky	11.94	10.88	6	2.33	2.67	3.05	2.83
79	Nirvana	Paul John	Single Malt	11.63	10.42	6	2.83	2.92	2.50	2.17
80	10 Year Old	Benriach	Single Malt	11.52	10.25	6	2.92	2.42	2.75	2.17
81	Kirin Single Grain Fuji	Kirin	Single Grain	11.47	10.17	6	3.08	2.67	2.25	2.17